Clash of Critters Tier List – Best Tatari to Evolve First

A complete Clash of Critters tier list for May 2026, covering S+ to D rankings, Tatari evolution planning, beginner-friendly picks, resource priority, and cautious investment guidance.

View Tier List Best First Evolution

Top evolution shortlist

BuddiPriority 1

DewgrubPriority 2

PunchimpPriority 3

TaptailPriority 4

VoltfawnPriority 5

Quick Answer: Best Tatari to Evolve First

The best Tatari to evolve first are the S+ Tier picks: Buddi, Dewgrub, Punchimp, Taptail, Voltfawn. In this Clash of Critters tier list, these are the safest early investments because they rank highest overall without requiring us to assume specific hidden skills or future balance changes.

Clash of Critters Tier List May 2026

This Clash of Critters tier list includes the complete S+ to D ranking with evolution priority, beginner suitability, and investment notes.

47 Tatari ranked

Tier	Tatari	Evolution Priority	Beginner Friendly	Notes
S+	Buddi	Very High	Yes	Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.
S+	Dewgrub	Very High	Yes	Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.
S+	Punchimp	Very High	Yes	Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.
S+	Taptail	Very High	Yes	Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.
S+	Voltfawn	Very High	Yes	Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.
S	Ashlarva	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Droppit	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Frugling	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Goonbug	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Manteeny	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Maskfry	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Pyropup	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Zappur	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
S	Zaplet	High	Yes	Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.
A	Cactobud	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
A	Cheerling	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
A	Frostnip	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
A	Pandaroo	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
A	Sealing	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
A	Souphog	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
A	Waddledo	Medium	Mostly	Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.
B	Cribbler	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Gibber	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Hootlet	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Sackling	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Shardsnail	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Sparkeet	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Sparkit	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Shrimpyro	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
B	Tindercub	Low	Situational	Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.
C	Blueflick	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Drilleroo	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Dumbopus	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Flameow	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Fluffle	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Fumekit	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Funglet	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Gopher	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Humbug	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Kittazap	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Lollama	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Rubblet	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Volkit	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
C	Zapuni	Avoid	No	Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.
D	Joeyo	Avoid	No	Lowest priority for evolution resources in this May 2026 ranking.
D	Lullelly	Avoid	No	Lowest priority for evolution resources in this May 2026 ranking.
D	Sinklet	Avoid	No	Lowest priority for evolution resources in this May 2026 ranking.

Buddi

S+

Evolution Priority: Very High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.

Dewgrub

S+

Evolution Priority: Very High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.

Punchimp

S+

Evolution Priority: Very High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.

Taptail

S+

Evolution Priority: Very High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.

Voltfawn

S+

Evolution Priority: Very High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Best first-evolution candidate if available and it fits your team.

Ashlarva

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Droppit

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Frugling

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Goonbug

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Manteeny

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Maskfry

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Pyropup

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Zappur

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Zaplet

Evolution Priority: High
Beginner Friendly: Yes
Notes: Strong investment after S+ picks or as a team-fit alternative.

Cactobud

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Cheerling

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Frostnip

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Pandaroo

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Sealing

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Souphog

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Waddledo

Evolution Priority: Medium
Beginner Friendly: Mostly
Notes: Good enough to build, but usually not the first place to spend rare resources.

Cribbler

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Gibber

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Hootlet

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Sackling

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Shardsnail

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Sparkeet

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Sparkit

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Shrimpyro

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Tindercub

Evolution Priority: Low
Beginner Friendly: Situational
Notes: Fine as a temporary option; keep evolution spending limited.

Blueflick

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Drilleroo

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Dumbopus

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Flameow

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Fluffle

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Fumekit

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Funglet

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Gopher

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Humbug

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Kittazap

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Lollama

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Rubblet

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Volkit

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Zapuni

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Do not overinvest early unless future balance changes improve its value.

Joeyo

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Lowest priority for evolution resources in this May 2026 ranking.

Lullelly

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Lowest priority for evolution resources in this May 2026 ranking.

Sinklet

Evolution Priority: Avoid
Beginner Friendly: No
Notes: Lowest priority for evolution resources in this May 2026 ranking.

S+

S+ Tier Summary

The safest first evolution targets in this guide. Prioritize these Tatari when you want broad value without relying on a narrow setup.

S Tier Summary

Strong evolution choices that are worth building after your main S+ option or when they better fit your current lineup.

A Tier Summary

Solid picks with medium priority. They can carry useful roles, but should usually wait behind S+ and S investments.

B Tier Summary

Usable while progressing, but low priority for scarce evolution resources unless you have a specific reason to build them.

C Tier Summary

Avoid heavy investment early. These Tatari may be temporary fillers, but they are not efficient first evolution targets.

D Tier Summary

Lowest evolution priority in this list. Save rare resources for higher-ranked Tatari unless the game changes.

How We Rank Tatari in This Tier List

This Clash of Critters tier list focuses on evolution priority and account progression. It avoids detailed ability claims and may change after balance updates.

Evolution efficiency

Higher tiers favor Tatari that are safer places to spend scarce evolution materials early.

Beginner reliability

Rankings prefer picks that are easy to recommend without assuming a perfect roster or advanced setup.

Long-term value

Tatari ranked higher should remain useful longer than short-term filler choices.

Risk of overinvestment

Lower tiers reflect caution where spending resources may slow account progress.

S+ Tier Tatari Explained

S+ Tier Tatari are the strongest first evolution recommendations in this guide. If you have one of these, it is usually the cleanest place to start before spreading resources across lower tiers.

Buddi

S+

Buddi is one of the best Tatari to evolve first in this Clash of Critters tier list. Prioritize it when you want a high-confidence early investment.

Dewgrub

S+

Dewgrub is one of the best Tatari to evolve first in this Clash of Critters tier list. Prioritize it when you want a high-confidence early investment.

Punchimp

S+

Punchimp is one of the best Tatari to evolve first in this Clash of Critters tier list. Prioritize it when you want a high-confidence early investment.

Taptail

S+

Taptail is one of the best Tatari to evolve first in this Clash of Critters tier list. Prioritize it when you want a high-confidence early investment.

Voltfawn

S+

Voltfawn is one of the best Tatari to evolve first in this Clash of Critters tier list. Prioritize it when you want a high-confidence early investment.

S Tier Tatari Explained

In this Clash of Critters tier list, S Tier Tatari are still strong evolution choices. They are best treated as high-priority options after your first S+ pick, or as practical alternatives when your roster does not include an S+ Tatari.

Ashlarva

Ashlarva is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Droppit

Droppit is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Frugling

Frugling is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Goonbug

Goonbug is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Manteeny

Manteeny is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Maskfry

Maskfry is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Pyropup

Pyropup is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Zappur

Zappur is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Zaplet

Zaplet is a high-priority Tatari in this ranking. Consider evolving it after your top option or when it better matches your current team needs.

Best Tatari for Beginners

Beginners using this Clash of Critters tier list should prioritize Tatari that are highly ranked and easy to justify as early evolution targets.

BuddiDewgrubTaptailVoltfawnAshlarvaPyropupZaplet

Tatari You Should Not Overinvest In

In this Clash of Critters tier list, lower-tier Tatari can still fill gaps, but rare evolution materials are usually better saved for higher-tier options.

JoeyoLullellySinkletBlueflickDumbopusZapuni

Clash of Critters Evolution Priority Guide

Use this Clash of Critters tier list priority order when deciding where to spend scarce evolution resources.

Abstract visual showing Tatari evolution resource priority from S+ to lower tiers

S+ Tier

Very High

Choose one first if available and it fits your current roster.

S Tier

High

Build after your top pick or when it solves an immediate team need.

A Tier

Medium

Consider after your main team has a stronger foundation.

B Tier

Low

Use as temporary support, but avoid early heavy spending.

C Tier

Avoid

Hold resources unless a future update changes the ranking.

D Tier

Avoid

Lowest priority for evolution materials right now.

Beginner Tips Before You Spend Evolution Resources

The Clash of Critters tier list is most useful before you commit rare resources, not after a low-priority Tatari is already heavily evolved.

Do not evolve a low-tier Tatari just because it is currently leveled.
Keep enough resources available for your first S+ or S Tier investment.
Build around the Tatari you actually have, but avoid forcing rare materials into C or D Tier picks.
Check for major updates before committing expensive evolution resources.

Best Tatari to Evolve First Shortlist

If you only want a short Clash of Critters tier list answer, start with Buddi, Dewgrub, Punchimp, Taptail, Voltfawn. Keep lower-tier evolutions on hold until your main team has a stronger foundation.

Latest Update

This Clash of Critters tier list was updated for May 2026 with a complete S+ to D ranking, evolution priority logic, beginner picks, and overinvestment warnings. Rankings should be rechecked after major patches or new Tatari releases.

FAQ

What is the best Tatari to evolve first in Clash of Critters?+

For May 2026, this Clash of Critters tier list recommends the S+ Tier Tatari: Buddi, Dewgrub, Punchimp, Taptail, and Voltfawn. Pick the one that best fits your current team and available resources.

Is this Clash of Critters tier list official?+

No. This is an independent fan-made guide based on general ranking criteria and cautious progression advice. It is not an official ranking from the Clash of Critters team.

Should beginners evolve only S+ Tier Tatari?+

Beginners using a Clash of Critters tier list should usually start with S+ or S Tier Tatari because evolution resources can be limited. A Tier picks can still be useful, but they are a lower priority.

Which Tatari should I avoid overinvesting in?+

Avoid spending rare evolution resources early on C and D Tier Tatari, especially Joeyo, Lullelly, Sinklet, Blueflick, Dumbopus, and Zapuni, unless a future update changes their value.

How often is this tier list updated?+

This page is marked as updated for May 2026. Rankings may change after patches, new Tatari releases, or major balance changes.

Does this guide include codes or rewards?+

No. This page is only a tier list and evolution priority guide. It does not publish or claim any Clash of Critters codes.

Disclaimer

This is an independent fan-made guide site for Clash of Critters. We are not affiliated with Farlight Games, Lilith Games, or the official Clash of Critters team. All game names, characters, and related marks belong to their respective owners.